Submitted by user on
Study Name
the Grameen America Program
Study Sharepoint ID
26601
Intervention (standard name)
Outcome domains examined
Strength of Evidence Tag
Reason for the Rating

This study received a high study quality rating because it is a low-attrition randomized controlled trial with no known issues that suggest the findings cannot be attributed to the intervention.

This study received a high study quality rating because it is a low-attrition randomized controlled trial with no known issues that suggest the findings cannot be attributed to the intervention.

Populations targeted
Settings in which the intervention was studied
Characteristics

Subgroups

Subgroup data - Female
No
Subgroup data - Male
No
Subgroup data - White
No
Subgroup data - Black
No
Percent immigrants
91.00
Percent female
100.00
Percent With a high school diploma or GED
66.40
Percent general low-income population
100.00
Percent Hispanic or Latino of any race
98.50
Percent unknown race
1.50
Mean age
41.00
Group formation formatted

Potential borrowers formed groups of five to participate in the program. Randomization of these five-person loan groups to intervention and comparison conditions occurred before any services were delivered (that is, before the Grameen America group attended continuous group training). From March 2014 to March 2017, 1,492 women in 300 loan groups enrolled in the evaluation. After a slow recruitment period using a 50/50 recruitment ratio, the evaluation team changed the ratio to 80/20 and later to 65/35. The statistical analysis adjusts for these changes. Overall, 70 percent of the sample participants were assigned to the intervention.

Study timing formatted

The study enrolled participants between March 2014 and March 2017; this report presented early evidence from six-month surveys, through September 2017. An interim evaluation report is scheduled to be released in 2020, and a final report will be available in 2021.

Study funding formatted

The Robin Hood Foundation funds the Grameen America evaluation; the study report was funded by Citi Community Development.

Sample Characteristics

The program serves women with incomes below the federal poverty line. At program entry, the average participant was 41 years old, Hispanic or Latina (99 percent), and not born in the United States (91 percent). One-quarter (27 percent) felt that they spoke English well. Half (50 percent) were working for an employer, and 73 percent were operating their own business. About two-thirds were parents of a child at home. For two-thirds, their highest credential earned was a high school diploma or GED certificate. Potential borrowers had to form groups of five to participate in the program.

Implementing organization formatted

Grameen America, a nonprofit organization.

Program history

Grameen America opened its first branch in 2008 in Queens, NY. Its model is based on and similar to the Grameen Bank microfinance lending program in Bangladesh in the 1970s. As of September 2018, Grameen America operated 20 branches in 13 cities in the United States.

Treatment condition formatted

The Grameen America program is a microfinance model that provides loans to women with low incomes in the United States who are seeking to start or expand their small businesses. Potential borrowers form a group of five to participate in the program. All five individuals in the group are required to know each other, live near each other, and each have a business purpose for a loan. The group members do not need to plan to operate similar businesses; each group member seeks an individual loan. Groups assigned to the intervention condition then enroll in Grameen America's mandatory continuous group training in which borrowers learn about interest rates, loan repayments, savings, credit establishment, asset accumulation, and the merits and risks of loans. Each member of the group then receives a loan from Grameen America and invests those loans to start or expand a business. Borrowers meet weekly with Grameen America staff to make loan repayments, continue training, and network with peers.

Comparison condition formatted

The Grameen America program is a microfinance model that provides loans to women with low incomes in the United States who are seeking to start or expand their small businesses. Potential borrowers form a group of five to participate in the program. Groups assigned to the comparison condition were not eligible for a loan from or any services offered by Grameen America.

Mandatory services formatted

Participation in the continuous group training and weekly meetings with Grameen America staff were both mandatory to receive the loan from Grameen America.

Timing of study formatted

The study did not describe how long participants receive services.

Program funding formatted

Not known

Setting details formatted

The Grameen America branch in Union City, NJ, opened for this study in 2014, serving Union City, Jersey City, Hoboken, and the surrounding areas in northern New Jersey. Grameen America is a microfinance lending institution based in the United States.

Delivered by public or private entity?
Private
Secondary domains examined

Material hardship; type of employment (self-employed and/or working for an employer); participant credit score

Earliest publication year
2019
Most recent publication year
2019
Manuscripts
Check edits flag
No
Primary Service
Financial education
Enrollment Period
March 2014 to March 2017
Intervention Duration
6.00
Subgroup data - Hispanic
No