Submitted by user on
Study Name
Housing with Peer Support versus Housing Assistance Without Peer Support
Study Sharepoint ID
28567.04
Evaluation name
Project H&ART
Strength of Evidence Tag
Reason for the Rating

This study received a low study quality rating because the implementation of the randomized controlled trial was compromised and it does not adjust estimated impacts for potentially important differences between the intervention and comparison groups.

This study received a low study quality rating because the implementation of the randomized controlled trial was compromised and the study does not adjust estimated impacts for potentially important differences between the intervention and comparison groups.

Populations targeted
Settings in which the intervention was studied

Subgroups

Subgroup data - Female
No
Subgroup data - Male
No
Subgroup data - White
No
Subgroup data - Black
No
Count age
0
Count Young Adults
0
Count Hard-to-employ
0
Count Disability
0
Count chronically ill
0
Count mentally ill
0
Count substance dependent
0
Count formerly incarcerated
0
Count Justice involved
0
Count limited work history
0
Count homeless
0
Count immigrants
0
Count refugees
0
Count veterans
0
Count female
0
Count Male
0
Count Any postsecondary education
0
Count With a high school diploma or GED
0
Count No high school diploma or GED
0
Count Married
0
Count Parents
0
Count Single Parents
0
Count Non-Custodial Parents
0
Count Employed
0
Count Self employed
0
Count Unemployed
0
Count Disconnected/discouraged workers
0
Count general low-income population
0
Count Very low income (as classified by the authors)
0
Count welfare population
0
Count long-term welfare recipients
0
Count Asian
0
Count Black or African American
0
Count Hispanic or Latino of any race
0
Count American Indian or Alaska Native
0
Count Pacific islander
0
Count White
0
Count White not Hispanic
0
Count More than one race
0
Count Unknown race
0
Count another race
0
Percent homeless
100.00
Percent female
11.90
Percent Male
88.10
Percent Parents
0.00
Percent Employed
51.20
Percent Unemployed
48.80
Percent Hispanic or Latino of any race
31.10
Percent American Indian or Alaska Native
17.10
Percent White not Hispanic
41.80
Percent another race
10.00
Group formation formatted

Once potential participants completed drug and alcohol detoxification, they received a baseline assessment by research staff to determine their eligibility for the study. Participants (known to be experiencing homelessness and have substance use disorders at intake) were deemed eligible if they had lived in or near Albuquerque, NM, for three months or more, did not have serious disabilities, and had no dependent children. Once they were determined eligible, participants were randomly assigned to one of three study groups. The intervention condition reviewed here was provided throughout the study duration. Due to implementation challenges, however, the comparison group condition that provided housing assistance without peer support was discontinued about eight months after the first participant was randomly assigned, and research staff replaced it with referrals to substance use treatment and transportation assistance without residential housing (replacement not reviewed here). At this point, research staff made the decision to only assign females (approximately 12 percent of the study sample) to one of the first two intervention conditions (the first of the conditions not reviewed here) to ensure they received housing. The analyses do not further adjust for differing probabilities of random assignment to the study conditions over time and by gender.

Study timing formatted

April 1991 to December 1993

Implementing organization formatted

The Lovelace Medical Foundation in collaboration with Albuquerque's Health Care for the Homeless (HCH) Clinic in partnership with St. Martin's Hospitality Center (SMC)

Treatment condition formatted

The intervention condition of housing with peer support provided medium-intensity services to adults experiencing homelessness who also had problems with alcohol. Participants had to have lived in or near Albuquerque, NM, for three months or more. (Participants could not have serious disabilities or dependent children.) All participants successfully completed a detoxification from alcohol at a residential treatment facility between 2 and 10 days before beginning services. Comparison group participants received cost-free housing from Project H&ART in a substance-free living environment accompanied by support from residence managers who were also recently in recovery from alcohol dependence. Residence managers encouraged comparison group participants to set personal goals and build peer support networks, but these outcomes were not enforced. Comparison group participants were required to (1) remain alcohol and drug free (as determined by random drug tests), (2) attend weekly community meetings, and (3) inform residence managers twice weekly about any other community services received.

Comparison condition formatted

The comparison condition of housing assistance without peer support provided low-intensity services to adults who were experiencing homelessness and had problems with alcohol. They had to have lived in or near Albuquerque, NM, for three months or more. (Participants could not have serious disabilities or dependent children.) Comparison participants received community-based housing (apartment or motel based) and random alcohol and drug testing. Participants were also required to monitor their use of substance abuse and rehabilitation services and other services received in the community twice per week. All comparison condition services were generally unsupervised. The comparison condition was terminated in December 1991, after 92 participants were randomly assigned to this condition, due to implementation issues and limitations in unsupervised design of services.

Mandatory services formatted

None

Setting details formatted

Project H&ART took place in Albuquerque, NM. Participants lived in program-provided apartments, and most program activities took place in a nearby office building.

Delivered by public or private entity?
Private
Secondary domains examined

Alcohol use; Housing stability

Earliest publication year
1993
Most recent publication year
1996
Manuscripts
Check edits flag
No
Primary Service
Case management
Subgroup data - Hispanic
No