Submitted by user on
Study Name
Breaking Barriers
Study Sharepoint ID
26582
Evaluation name
Breaking Barriers
Intervention (standard name)
Strength of Evidence Tag
Reason for the Rating

This study received a high study quality rating because it is a low-attrition randomized controlled trial with no known issues that suggest the findings cannot be attributed to the intervention.

This study received a high study quality rating because it is a low-attrition randomized controlled trial with no known issues that suggest the findings cannot be attributed to the intervention.

Populations targeted
Settings in which the intervention was studied
Count age
0
Count Young Adults
0
Count Hard-to-employ
0
Count Disability
1061
Count chronically ill
0
Count mentally ill
0
Count substance dependent
0
Count formerly incarcerated
0
Count Justice involved
0
Count limited work history
0
Count homeless
0
Count immigrants
0
Count refugees
0
Count veterans
0
Count female
0
Count Male
0
Count Any postsecondary education
0
Count With a high school diploma or GED
0
Count No high school diploma or GED
0
Count Married
0
Count Parents
0
Count Single Parents
0
Count Non-Custodial Parents
0
Count Employed
0
Count Self employed
0
Count Unemployed
0
Count Disconnected/discouraged workers
0
Count general low-income population
0
Count Very low income (as classified by the authors)
0
Count welfare population
0
Count long-term welfare recipients
0
Count Asian
0
Count Black or African American
0
Count Hispanic or Latino of any race
0
Count American Indian or Alaska Native
0
Count Pacific islander
0
Count White
0
Count More than one race
0
Count Unknown race
0
Count another race
0
Percent Disability
100.00
Percent mentally ill
86.00
Percent substance dependent
34.00
Percent female
54.00
Percent Male
46.00
Percent Any postsecondary education
21.00
Percent No high school diploma or GED
19.00
Percent With a high school diploma or GED
81.00
Percent Married
18.00
Percent Black or African American
15.00
Percent Hispanic or Latino of any race
35.00
Percent White not Hispanic
40.00
Mean age
40.00
Group formation formatted

Individuals were recruited for the study if they (1) were at least 18 years old, (2) were a resident of San Diego County in California, (3) had a self-identified mental or physical disability, (4) had low income, (5) were not working or were underemployed, and (6) were a participant of California's TANF program, California's vocational rehabilitation service agency, or a San Diego County behavioral health service program. Eligible individuals who consented to enroll in the study were randomly assigned to the intervention or comparison condition. In total, 528 individuals were randomly assigned to the intervention group, and 533 individuals were randomly assigned to the comparison group. Evaluators completed analyses at the individual level, excluding any veterans who received Breaking Barriers services from the analysis to comply with federal funding requirements. Analysis also excluded sample members who reported that their English-speaking abilities were limited at the time of study enrollment.

Study timing formatted

The study enrolled individuals in January 2017 and through November 2017. Follow-up occurred 15 months after random assignment, on average.

Study funding formatted

The study was also funded by the grant from the U.S. Department of Labor and satisfied program funding requirements to conduct an evaluation.

Sample Characteristics

The full research sample that was randomly assigned were mostly between the ages of 24 and 59 and spoke English as their primary language. About half were female. Common self-identified disabilities included mental health disorders (86 percent), substance use (34 percent), musculoskeletal injury/connective disorder (21 percent), and developmental/learning (18 percent). Most research sample members had a high school diploma or GED certificate (61 percent). Less than half had been employed in the past year (42 percent), though most had some employment history (92 percent). Few were receiving TANF benefits (28 percent) or SSI/SSDI (22 percent). The research sample was 40 percent White, non-Hispanic; 35 percent Hispanic; 15 percent Black, non-Hispanic; and 10 percent Other.

Implementing organization formatted

Breaking Barriers was designed and overseen by the San Diego Workforce Partnership, the county workforce investment board, which contracted with American Job Centers to provide services. Three job centers were operated by nationwide private providers and one was operated by a local school district.

Program history

The intervention started a year prior to the study, in January 2016, and operated through June 2018.

Treatment condition formatted

Breaking Barriers provided Individual Placement and Support (IPS) services within American Job Centers to eligible individuals with low income who had a self-identified disability. IPS services included career counseling, job search assistance, job development, personalized benefits counseling, referrals to supportive services, and follow-along support after individuals found a job. Employment specialists who provided IPS services maintained small caseloads in order to provide participants with individualized support.

Comparison condition formatted

The individuals assigned to the comparison condition received a list of other publicly available resources in the community

Mandatory services formatted

None

Timing of study formatted

On average, participants were active in the program for almost 10 months.

Program funding formatted

Breaking Barriers was funded by a grant from the U.S. Department of Labor’s Workforce Innovation Fund.

Setting details formatted

The intervention took place at four American Job Centers in San Diego County, California.

Secondary domains examined

Physical health status; mental health status

Earliest publication year
2019
Most recent publication year
2019
Manuscripts
Check edits flag
No
Primary Service
Individual Placement and Support
Enrollment Period
January 2017 to November 2017
Intervention Duration
10.00
Intervention Cost
$3730
Comparison cost
$2069