Submitted by user on
Study Name
Partners for a Competitive Workforce: Construction Sector Partnership
Study Sharepoint ID
26712.03
Evaluation name
Quasi-Experimental Impact Study of NFWS/SIF Workforce Partnership Programs
Strength of Evidence Tag
Reason for the Rating

This study received a moderate study quality rating because it is a quasi-experimental design that establishes that the intervention and comparison groups are similar at baseline and adjusts impact estimates to account for any minor differences in the gro

This study received a moderate study quality rating because it is a quasi-experimental design that establishes that the intervention and comparison groups are similar at baseline and adjusts impact estimates to account for any minor differences in the groups.

Populations targeted
Settings in which the intervention was studied

Subgroups

Subgroup data - Female
No
Subgroup data - Male
No
Subgroup data - White
No
Subgroup data - Black
No
Percent female
48.00
Percent Male
52.00
Percent Any postsecondary education
28.00
Percent No high school diploma or GED
17.00
Percent With a high school diploma or GED
83.00
Percent Unemployed
100.00
Percent Black or African American
78.00
Percent White not Hispanic
19.00
Percent another race
3.00
Group formation formatted

Unemployed workers and new labor force entrants interested in construction jobs were enrolled in the program. Participants enrolled from January 2010 to February 2012. Workers who were employed at enrollment were excluded from the study. Using propensity score matching, evaluators found a comparison group of similar unemployed workers who were located in the same area and pursued state employment and training services during the same period. Job seekers in the two study conditions were matched on individual characteristics and employment history. The program enrolled 379 unemployed participants, and 36,859 comparison group members were selected as matches out of 55,754 possible comparison group members.

Study timing formatted

Participants enrolled from January 2010 to February 2012. Their outcomes were analyzed through the end of 2012.

Study funding formatted

A National Fund for Workforce Solutions grant from the Social Innovation Fund funded the study.

Sample Characteristics

The majority of the participants in the study were Black (78 percent) and had at least a high school diploma or a GED (83 percent). Almost half of the participants were female (48 percent), and about one third (31 percent) were younger than age 25 and one third (29 percent) between age 25 and 34. All participants were unemployed at the time of program entry.

Implementing organization formatted

Partners for a Competitive Workforce collaborative, a regional partnership of Workforce Investment Boards, employers, community colleges, vocational schools, the Associated Builder and Contractors, the Independent Electrical Contractors, and the Greater Cincinnati Apprenticeship Council.

Program history

The program was established in 2009.

Treatment condition formatted

Unemployed workers with low skills, including new labor market entrants and inexperienced workers, were recruited into the program and prepared to enter a construction career such as carpentry; electrical; plumbing and pipefitting; or heating, ventilation, air conditioning, and refrigeration. The program aimed to enroll workers who were female or non-White. The Construction Sector Partnership was formed to create and improve construction career pathways in the region, with an emphasis on developing educational pathways. The program offered pre-apprenticeship programs with its employer partners, through which workers received on-the-job training to prepare them for entry-level construction jobs. The program also offered work-readiness training and job search assistance to participants.

Comparison condition formatted

Unemployed workers in the comparison group could receive state employment and training services from the Ohio employment exchange agency.

Mandatory services formatted

None

Timing of study formatted

The study does not specify the duration of service receipt.

Program funding formatted

The program was funded through a National Fund for Workforce Solutions grant from the Social Innovation Fund in addition to sources including the U.S. Department of Labor and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

Setting details formatted

Greater Cincinnati, OH

Secondary domains examined

None

Earliest publication year
2016
Most recent publication year
2016
Manuscripts
Check edits flag
No
Primary Service
Occupational or sectoral training
Enrollment Period
June 2015 to July 2017
Subgroup data - Hispanic
No